H. G. Muller wrote on Sat, Apr 1, 2023 02:16 AM EDT:
I suppose that David uses the term 'early promotions' not so much to refer to promotions before the last rank is reached, but to promotion so early in the game that nothing has been captured yet. And I agree that this rule doesn't really make a more interesting game, but seems purely conceived for the convenience of playing it with woodware, without the need for extra pieces. (Which seems a bit strange, as it would still need two extra Pawns and pieces per player, presumably from a second orthodox set, which would leave plenty of spare pieces available for promotion.
On the other hand, one could argue that it is a nice tactical dilemma that when you are planning a promotion you should also take care something worthwhile is traded by the time you reach last rank. This happens so rarely, however, that it doesn't seem worth to complicate the rules for making it possible.
Note that although the orthodox game shown by David does have an early promotion, but not one where the promoted Pawn survives.
I suppose that David uses the term 'early promotions' not so much to refer to promotions before the last rank is reached, but to promotion so early in the game that nothing has been captured yet. And I agree that this rule doesn't really make a more interesting game, but seems purely conceived for the convenience of playing it with woodware, without the need for extra pieces. (Which seems a bit strange, as it would still need two extra Pawns and pieces per player, presumably from a second orthodox set, which would leave plenty of spare pieces available for promotion.
On the other hand, one could argue that it is a nice tactical dilemma that when you are planning a promotion you should also take care something worthwhile is traded by the time you reach last rank. This happens so rarely, however, that it doesn't seem worth to complicate the rules for making it possible.
Note that although the orthodox game shown by David does have an early promotion, but not one where the promoted Pawn survives.