Comments/Ratings for a Single Item
Still one of the best solutions for a large board. The set of pieces is quite conservative, but that may be the reason why it works. They consist merely of the most logical extensions of the classical set. The set is well balanced. There are more leapers than sliders, but that's good for the board at first is a bit crowdy. The foxes in front of the pawns are placed very well. They effectively close the game, hindering advancement of pieces. Whithout them opening play wouldn't work nicely. The game mimics well the proceedings of a real life battle, much better than Classical Chess and even better than Shatranj. This feature is geneally one of the pleasant things when playing large chess variants
A massive variant with lots of strong pieces. Maybe not as easy to play as any number of large board variants, but it leaves an impression when you first see it.
It is not clear to me what happens when a Pawn is on 9th rank, and nothing of that color is captured yet. Is the move to 10th rank now forbidden? Or would the Pawn just stay a Pawn? (This could make sense to capture something.) If the move to 10th rank is forbidden, would it still check a King on 10th rank? Things would not be as complex if a Pawn was also allowed to promote to Fox (even though none was captured) on 10th rank.
Renniassance Chess
It is not clear to me what happens when a Pawn is on 9th rank, and nothing of that color is captured yet. Is the move to 10th rank now forbidden? Or would the Pawn just stay a Pawn? (This could make sense to capture something.) If the move to 10th rank is forbidden, would it still check a King on 10th rank?
I think we should follow the Grand Chess rules for promote-by-replacement. A pawn cannot move to the 10th rank if there is nothing to promote to, but it can still give check. This would never happen in a real game anyway.
The Castle is lacking the Alfil move in the diagram.
Ai, sloppy. I did check the moves, of course, but I really thought it was moving this way. Now that I read back the description, I cannot imagine why I thought that...
I see that the diagram was already put in the article by an editor, so I cannot fix it myself.
The diagram on the page has been corrected.
Great! Thanks.
15 comments displayed
Permalink to the exact comments currently displayed.